dr_tectonic: (Default)
[personal profile] dr_tectonic
Just got back from a coffee talk about sinkholes and related hazards in Florida. Now, in the course of my job I've been exposed over the last couple years to a lot of information about hazards, natural and otherwise, and while I'm no expert (and this is just my opinion, and should not be considered in any way an official statement by anybody), I have come to the following conclusion:

Do. NOT. Live. In. Florida.

Seriously. The place is freakin' DOOMED. Aside from the hurricanes (which will just be getting worse in the future), the natural resource limitation issues (too many people, not enough groundwater), and the fact that most of the peninsula will likely be underwater in a century or two as sea levels rise from global warming, the entire damn state sits on a carbonate platform.

Carbonates dissolve in fresh water. And when you remove part of the ground beneath you, eventually the rest of it collapses into a big sinkhole.

The anthropogenic influences on sinkhole development are HUGE. People pull fresh water out of the water table to bathe, drink, clean, irrigate (lawns are evil!) and so on, and all of that water, "dirty" but still fresh (i.e., not saline) ends up getting pumped deep into the ground to flow back to the ocean -- dissolving the rocks as it goes. Adding more people makes it worse.

Guess where all the baby boomers are moving?

And there's not a damn thing that can be done about it.

The basic problem, the really fundamental problem here, is that in the U.S. (as in most places), people are allowed to go anyplace they want, build a house, and live there. Whether or not it's bad for the environment, or the economy, or society, or civilization in general. I'm coming to the conclusion that this was a bad societal choice, design-wise.

Date: 2005-01-04 09:41 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] dr-tectonic.livejournal.com
Yeah, it's a dilemma. I think that probably the only really good solution involves smaller populations and better distribution of wealth.

We aren't quite screwed when it comes to water... yet. Planners are worrying about it, but people still want to move to Colorado and it's almost impossible to prevent. The really big problem is that the agreements divvying up the water from the Colorado River basin were made during a 40-year anomalous high, so they actually allocate more water than exists normally, let along during droughts.

Oh, and have I mentioned that lawns are evil? Lawns and golf courses.

Date: 2005-01-05 05:38 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] melted-snowball.livejournal.com
Smaller populations are tough when it basically summarizes to putting a "we didn't really mean it" sign on the base of the Statue of Liberty. What to tell the equivalents of your ancestors or mine?

Date: 2005-01-05 05:41 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] melted-snowball.livejournal.com
Oh, and yes, golf courses are evil.

Lawns...well, they're stupid in places with water issues. Here, they're not so much of a big deal that way; they mostly exist to keep up the idea of living in a park, and they're very convenient as a place for the dog to do her business...

Oh, yeah, and they exploit middle class people's leisure time so they do less volunteering. So that's bad.

But I think they're really freaking stupid in places like New Mexico, or [shudder] Palm Springs...